In 2023, the cost of policing to Canadian taxpayers closed in on $20 billion for the first time. While annual police budgets continue to grow, there is little debate in the media about its cost to taxpayers and the value for money in relation to crime reduction.
This 50 per cent increase over inflation in the cost of policing from 20 years ago is now coinciding with disturbing increases in violent crime. Homicides are up, stoking public fear. Violent crime has returned to levels seen 20 years ago. Canada’s homicide rate is second only to the United States among G7 countries, and is rising as the American rate drops.
The rate of homicide involving Indigenous victims is six times that of non-Indigenous people, and it’s three times higher for Black men.
With one in three women experiencing some form of violence in their lifetimes, intimate partner and sexual violence is now recognized as being at epidemic levels.
The majority of policing costs are paid from municipal taxes and have risen faster than expenditures on transit or social services. The cost of policing at the municipal level per capita varies considerably from a high of $496 annually for Vancouver to a low of $217 in Québec City.
Though much of the rhetoric for justifying increasing police budgets is about crime, an analysis of trends over the last 20 years in Canada could not find any correlation between increases in municipal police budgets and a reduction in crime rates.
Our review of studies in the United Kingdom and the United States shows that investments in programs tackling risk factors give better returns than innovations like problem-oriented policing.
The answer is mental healthcare and economic opportunities. If you’ve ever been to a local jail, you’ll quickly realize that the majority of people there needed a mental health intervention in their early childhood. Problem is that there’s no will by anyone to do it. Parents are resistant because of the stigma. Even if they’re not, the cost of mental healthcare is too high if it’s not covered by insurance. Even if it’s covered you get a p-doc once a month for 15 minutes. Nevermind trying to get a diagnosis from a child who can’t explain their symptoms because their symptoms are just normal for them in the first place. Then you have to try different medications at different doses and get everyone on board to take the medication on time every day. That’s all if you can get a doctor that listens to what a kid says. Doing all this as an adult is exhausting, can’t imagine trying to do it as a kid and having to trust a number of other adults not to fuck up.