If you’ve ever used TikTok, Instagram, or X/Twitter, you will already be familiar with centralised social media.Centralised social media means big company owns the app, controls the software, and keeps all your data.
  • N0t_5ure@lemmy.worldEnglish
    1·
    7 hours ago

    Thank you for posting this, as I am fairly new to Lemmy and this article hits an issue I have a question about:

    Post a video on PeerTube? It can show up on Mastodon. That’s like uploading a YouTube video and your Twitter followers seeing it automatically without you having to repost and clunkily embed it.

    So they’ve said that a post on one federated app “can” show up on show up on another. Does that mean that it always does? Is there anything you have to do have your content appear on other platforms? If I make a text post here on lemmy, how can it appear on something like peertube or pixelfed? That doesn’t make sense to me. Can someone please enlighten me?

    • BakedCatboy@lemmy.mlEnglish
      3·
      7 hours ago

      It all just depends on whether it makes sense or not, and also whether the developers of each software coordinated to make it translate.

      Like you point out, text posts don’t exist on a video platform (at least if you’re not counting youtube community posts), so peertube devs didn’t write any code to receive or display them.

      How you get stuff to show up also depends on the platform, but I believe most will do it if you search the account handle of the account on the other service - so you can follow a peertube account from mastodon by searching @account@example.com and then it starts showing newly posted videos in your feed.

      Since all the translations are decided by the devs of each software, some of it is a little funky - like IIRC lemmy communities are displayed in Mastodon as an account that you can follow, and each post to the community is a post on that account (or maybe it’s boosted by that account, I can’t remember), so if you follow the “community account” from Mastodon, you will start seeing new posts in your Mastodon feed, and can reply to the comments by replying to the post. You can also post to the community from Mastodon by mentioning the community at the beginning of a Mastodon post, and I think it will boost it.

      It’s kinda weird IMO - I get the feeling a lot of posts from Mastodon in Lemmy communities might be made by accident because it often looks like the Mastodon user was just trying to tag an organization (like tagging @Plex or @Netflix to complain about their software or something) and then saw the account suggestion from Lemmy and didn’t realize they would be posting to a community instead of tagging an individual.

      • N0t_5ure@lemmy.worldEnglish
        1·
        7 hours ago

        Thank you so much for taking the time to explain this. So if I post a meme to c/tenforward, people on mastodon and pixelfed can see it if they subscribe to @tenforward, is that correct? How can I tell if a post I’m seeing on lemmy originated on mastodon, pixelfed, etc.? For example, this post about unclogging a toilet. I can see that it was posted by SomeAmateur@sh.itjust.works. I assumed that the “@sh.itjust.works” part just pertained to the instance of lemmy the post originated from. If this post had come from mastodon, would there be more info somewhere from which I can tell the origin? Thanks.

        • BakedCatboy@lemmy.mlEnglish
          2·
          5 hours ago

          So if I post a meme to c/tenforward, people on mastodon and pixelfed can see it if they subscribe to @tenforward, is that correct?

          Yep! I’m not sure how it works for pixelfed but I think I remember something about text posts so I would assume it works the same there.

          Afaik the way to tell if a user is on Mastodon vs Lemmy/mbin/etc is if the instance part of their username is a path instead of a bare domain, it’s something like user@instance.com/users or something that includes “user” in the path, I can’t remember exactly and I can’t find an example but if you look at usernames enough you’ll find one.

          Edit: Actually maybe that changed because I found a comment from Mastodon and it looks normal just with a domain that you can see is a mastodon instance when you visit it, so idk ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

          Edit 2: I double checked in the sync app and it looks like users from mastodon show up as someone@instance.com/users/someone so it looks like it’s a UI specific thing

          • N0t_5ure@lemmy.worldEnglish
            1·
            5 hours ago

            Thank you so much!

            Actually maybe that changed because I found a comment from Mastodon and it looks normal just with a domain that you can see is a mastodon instance when you visit it, so idk ¯_(ツ)_/¯

            Could you please link to the example comment referenced? I want to check it out. Thanks.