• 134 Posts
  • 88 Comments
Joined 10 months ago
cake
Cake day: November 12th, 2023

help-circle











  • I suspect that that was a retcon - that the author wasn’t satisfied with the master character for whatever reason, or maybe just preferred Uruchika (as do I), so just ended up shifting the focus to Uruchika. And then had to do… something. And this was it.

    It is sort of odd, but there jave been periods during which Chikagecwas basically incommunicado so it’s not entirely out of line. I think it’ll work out, and if the series runs long enough, the master will get a chance to be a recurring character.






  • Go mom!

    This is an odd situation. Mom’s basically right about Sanda, and about Yagiuda’s effect on him - Sanda really has been conned into being submissive to adults who mean him harm. But at this point, Sagiuda isn’t one of them. He’s sincere. But that’s part of the problem.

    Sanda’s earnest and naive and sort of willfully ignorant. He’s not very good at thinking about difficult things and he’d rather not do it. And Yagiuda provided some crucial feedback to him early on - he was the first adult that Sanda decided to go ahead and trust anyway, when he really shouldn’t have. And just sort of coincidentally, Yagiuda really ended up more or less worthy of that trust, so Sanda could just ignore all the difficult stuff and go back to being a dumb kid and get away with it, and he did.

    But now that’s become a pattern. Whenever he’s faced with an adult who means him harm, he wants to go ahead and trust them and submit to them so he can just keep on being a dumb kid. And it’s not working out for him like it did with Yagiuda, but he’s so busy being a dumb kid that he’s not aware of that.

    So it’s arguably a good thing that mom is stepping in to show him that some people just cannot be trusted ever and really need to be dealt with fully. It’s just sort of unfortunate that she’s directing that against someone who actually can be trusted, rather than one of the many (most notably the headmaster) who really do need to be dealt with… with extreme prejudice.

    Curious to see how this plays out…



  • Finally caught up with this.

    First, it’s notable that it took this long to read 28 chapters, and a reflection of the fact that it was a slog.

    And it’s either the case that the “last chapter” bit is misleading or that it was entirely unexpectedly axed, since the story isn’t even close to wrapping up.

    I really can’t recommend it. It’s not entirely awful, and there’s still some intriguing mysteries that might shift the tone a bit, but as it is the story is too rushed and superficial, and pretty much every character, and most notably the protagonist, are all some variety of loathsome POS. In fact, the few characters who weren’t utterly loathsome were apparently there solely to be murdered, and just as likely murdered by the protagonist as by the supposed villains.

    I’m not sure if I’m going to keep following it or not. There’s one specific mystery that’s been broadly hinted at that could undermine everything - could make the protagonist manipulated and/or delusional instead of what he appears to be - just a smug, self-absorbed and entirely conscienceless POS. I still want to give NISIOISIN the benefit of the doubt but…
















  • Ah… that made me laugh. 😄

    Okay then - is it going to take long for some serious reveals? My guess is no - that’s most of why I’m patient. It feels like things are finally moving fairly quickly toward a direct confrontation between Remilia and Pina, and that’s when it’s all going to come to a head. And that’s when, if Emi is indeed watching, we’re going to find out.

    Can you be patient? Can I be patient?



  • The big mystery to me is whether Emi’s watching, and if so what she thinks.

    That last scene of Remilia was a bit over the top. Emi was definitely a good influence on her, but there’s always been the possibility that Emi wasn’t entirely right - that at least some portion of Remilia’s villainy was inherent, and is going to reveal itself in spite of Emi’s influence.

    I suspect we’re going to find out relatively soon. The story sort of languished for a while, as Remilia slowly positioned herself, but things appear to be moving pretty quickly now.