Mastodon

Have you ever considered that the Prime Directive is not only not ethical, but also illogical, and perhaps morally indefensible?

  • 1.44K Posts
  • 1.19K Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 11th, 2023

help-circle








  • More than an omen, an identical lineage might be engineered to similar effects — in which case we are uncomfortably close to the magical thinking of eugenics.

    I would guess that it wouldn’t work, though - the laws of magic would probably insist on it being genuine happenstance.

    I unfortunately don’t think we’ll see the Rani applying the actual scientific method to what she’s doing - her experimentation seems to be done, and she’s moved on to application.

    I think she’s retained her sense of purpose, though, which sets her apart from the more chaotic Master.





  • though I guess not overtly racist

    I was shocked, too.

    Not sure why he wished for giant skeleton monsters

    I was wondering about that - since they’re only sort-of “there,” I wonder if they’re a creation of the Rani’s. In “Unleashed” they talked about how the bones of the bone palace are largely based on birds…they played it off as simply being designed that way because they look cool, but…is there some significance?

    Another thing about Conrad: they did an interesting job portraying him as a victim in his own right, with Mrs. Flood still serving as his jailor, and, sort of creepily, as a mother figure.












  • I thought there was going to be more of a payoff to the surname Zufall (“coincidence”), which seems to contradict the wish granting thing we got.

    Oh, interesting - I didn’t realize that was the translation. I guess that ties in to “The Church on Ruby Road” and how luck and coincidences can affect reality, in this case leading to Desidirum. A bit of a deep cut that I barely remembered.

    The bone beasts were an impressive visual, but I’m not sure what purpose they served other than spectacle?

    That’s sort of my issue with episodes of this nature in general - we know it’s not real, it will (probably) be undone by the end of the season, so a lot of it is just there to be weird.

    I was not sold on Rogue’s love letter from hell

    Me neither, though I was not as high on “Rogue” as many people were last year. Hopefully it’s leading to a more significant return soon, and doesn’t fizzle out like the Captain Jack cameo during the Chibnall run, though I’m sure that one imploded for very different reasons.

    Fuck off Conrad, have another pink fat sandwich for the road.

    I really did enjoy the ways in which Conrad’s shitty worldview infested this world. I’m sure the Rani was all too happy to let that happen, fostering doubts in those whose lives were less than ideal.

    The undercurrent that questioning dominant narratives can crack their grasp on reality is more powerful and relevant than it felt at a first viewing.

    Agreed - this is one of those episodes that throws some really compelling ideas out there, without really slowing down to examine them.

    And it’s of course very RTD to place one of the perspectives through cracks in (normative) reality with the marginalised dispossessed

    The line about Ruby walking past their encampment every day and ignoring it was…not subtle (and that’s a good thing - I’m over subtlety).

    Omega

    Another classic thing that I’m aware of, but will have to do some homework on.

    On the whole, I’m with you. It was a decent episode, I was entertained, but by its nature it’s mostly an exercise in table-setting for the big finale.