Join Andy Zaltzman, Babatunde Aléshé, Emma Sidi, Jack Dee & Rosie Jones in Series 18
I just Rosie Jones on something talking about taking a first date to a posh restaurant and then seeing Greg, Alex, and Tim Key at a table, and her being torn about wanting to give her attention to her date but also really wanting to be on Taskmaster. I’m glad at least one worked out.
Hard pass on Daniel Tosh. Didn’t really like his ‘bro’ humor to begin with - and then he joked about how funny it’d be if a woman in his audience got raped after she heckled him. Same as I wouldn’t like Jimmy Carr as a long term host. He’s great on cats and such, but that’s not the tone I’d like for taskmaster. Mulaney might be good, but I don’t know how he handles improv also might just be a bit too much of a personality. If Craig Ferguson in still in the states I think he’d be good as well.
I mean, they’d never have picked Tosh for those reasons, McHale is the same style, but way more family friendly.
But come on, even Greg Davies wouldn’t fly in America, that’s why they got Reggie and just had him be nice.
The taskmaster has to act like a dick at least 75% of the time for the show to work. Its like the entire premise of the show. There’s not many American comedians that act like dicks but are actually good people.
We’ve got dicks that act like dicks (Tosh), dicks that act like nice people (Mulaney) and a handful of people that are probably really dicks, sometimes act like dicks, but mostly act like a morning TV show host (McHale).
It’s just a cultural divide.
Maybe Mulaney today as he’s more openly embracing his dickishness, but when American Taskmaster happened, I’m pretty sure he was still doing the sweet innocent act in his stand-ups. I don’t think it was till that Pete Holmes sitcom about standup where he started to embrace it, and even then the joke was that John Mulaney of all people, wouldn’t be a dick.
Maybe you know something I don’t, but I’m not aware of horrendous comments towards large demographics from Davies
When did Tosh do that?
And why wasn’t that in your first comment about why you wouldn’t want him?
If that’s what you’re calling his response to one specific person who was heckling him…
Greg has said much more wide sweeping things directed at demographics just on Taskmaster.
Those were jokes, just like I’m sure Tosh wasn’t legitimately saying it would be funny if a woman in his audience was actually being raped.
I do understand why you don’t like Jimmy Carr now, just not sure why you like any British comedy
I was asking what Davis said on that level. Saying a woman should be raped is a statement towards a large demographic.
Davis is also an actor, and is playing a roll. He makes awful statements on Alex Horne’s behalf, but we know it’s in jest.
I was raised on British comedy - satire in particular. Tosh’s retort wasn’t satire. I don’t know why you’re being such a simp for a guy who went out of fashion ages ago.